Hi, There are many people I know and also many comment sections I see online that are just parroting Israeli and US state department propaganda and I feel like it is driving me insane. They seem to repeat arguments using almost every common propaganda technique available and it seems like the majority of people is just falling for it without any critical thinking and this is depressing as hell.
They are portraying fascism as the only solution to all problems and as a justified position but don’t even want to name it as such, saying everyone else is the fascist.
I think I am going mad what should I do, I feel like arguing against it is like speaking to a wall most of the time.
Thank you.
It’s not just related to Gaza etc, to everything else too (immigrats etc). Everyone is just kicking down on others of their class instead of seeing who really plays us out against each other.
The thing is, I wrote this here because sometimes I feel like a psycho with the anger I have towards this fcked up system we live under, while other seem to be okay with it and just dont care.
And I dont mean online conversations btw, I deleted social media long ago already, but I read youtube comments of news sites sometimes (granted, many are bots, but still).
Other comrades irl told me that it is best to just be a likeable person when trying to convice a propagandised person of your views, but I cannot help but get ‘enraged’ sometimes when some people repeat the most heinous shit ever without even knowing what they are really repeating there and then defend it over some optics politics or some percieved behaviour of the opposite political group. I don’t know, the more I have to deal with these idiots I understand some actions of people like Stalin more and more even if they seem harsh from a first look, but when you get into it, it does make sense.
I definitely get it. In one argument I even said “do you want me to to First Reformed mode or what” (watch that film, by the way, highly recommend to any leftist) because I felt extremely frustrated at how people couldn’t even follow a simple argument about how it was necessary to warn students about the role of military contractors before they signed up to work with them. It’s really tiring to be the one crazy person saying something that feels obvious to you, but everyone else looks at you like you’re a flat earther.
But I would also warn you about the sense of elitism that this position brings with it. It’s really common that when you start reading Marx and everything about the world starts clicking together you’ll feel like a high wizard, it’s something “like a university degree in truth” (from Disco Elysium) that makes you feel very special. But those beliefs aren’t useful unless they can be put to work by convincing sufficient numbers of people of their utility and getting them to enact a program. And the nice thing about Marxism is that it doesn’t just explain how capital accumulates, it also explains how political power works on an ideological level, and why it’s difficult to surpass false consciousness. I don’t know if you read the essay, but I’ll go ahead and recommend it again because right from the start it addresses this frustration but it offers a perspective that will help you.
And more concretely, I don’t know how much I’d recommend being “likeable” as a tactic. It’s nice to have good optics. But sometimes you’ll have better optics and a better message if you come across as mature, measured, and considerate than just likeable or charismatic. Personally, I like to listen carefully and take time before replying if I’m in a good faith political conversation (if it’s bad faith then I channel
) and I’m usually more concerned with offering the other person the same feeling of “wow everything makes sense now” that you get when you read theory, than I am trying to come across as likeable. But if you’re doing outreach, mutual aid work, or similar then a more charismatic tone is obviously more appropriate.